TMS vs MeRT

TMS and MeRT are innovative techniques for non-invasive brain stimulation. While both utilize magnetic fields to modulate neural activity, they differ significantly in their methodologies, applications, and personalization levels. As these treatments gain traction for various neurological and psychiatric conditions, understanding their distinct features becomes crucial for patients seeking alternative solutions beyond traditional medications. This article highlights the key differences between TMS and MeRT, helping readers make informed decisions about their care.

TMS vs MeRT

Home » TMS vs MeRT: What Are the Differences?

Table Of Contents

What Is TMS?

Transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) is a non-invasive procedure that uses electromagnetic fields to stimulate nerve cells in the brain. This technology delivers focused pulses to specific neural regions associated with mood regulation and other functions. FDA-approved since 2008, TMS has become an established treatment option for various neuropsychiatric conditions, especially when medications have not provided adequate relief. Here are the main types of magnetic brain stimulation:

Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (rTMS)

rTMS involves delivering multiple pulses at specific intervals to a targeted area over several sessions. Standard protocols typically generate these pulses at either 1 Hz (low-frequency) to reduce neural activity or 10 Hz (high-frequency) to increase stimulation.

Deep Transcranial Brain Stimulation (dTMS)

dTMS utilizes specialized H-coils that generate magnetic fields capable of penetrating deeper brain structures than standard TMS devices. This functionality allows practitioners to target regions that may be inaccessible with conventional technology, potentially providing benefits for specific mental health conditions.

Theta Burst Stimulation (TBS)

TBS delivers bursts of high-frequency magnetic pulses in patterns that mimic natural theta waves in the brain. The accelerated protocol can significantly reduce treatment time from the typical 40-minute sessions of standard rTMS to just 3-10 minutes, while maintaining comparable efficacy for conditions like major depressive disorder.

What Is MeRT?

Magnetic e-resonance therapy (MeRT) is an evolution of TMS that combines magnetic stimulation with real-time qEEG monitoring for highly personalized procedures. Unlike standard techniques, this innovative approach first maps an individual’s unique neural activity patterns through qEEG analysis, then customizes the treatment parameters specifically for that patient’s neurophysiology. High personalization leads to precise therapy based on objective brain measurements rather than standardized protocols, potentially offering advantages for complex neurological and psychiatric conditions.

Differences Between TMS and MeRT

Technology Used

TMS and MeRT both use magnetic pulses to stimulate neural activity, but they diverge significantly in their technological approaches. TMS involves standardized protocols with fixed frequencies and intensities based on established guidelines. MeRT incorporates quantitative electroencephalogram (qEEG) readings to create a more dynamic treatment program that adapts to the individual’s specific neural patterns and responses.

Personalization

Standard TMS protocols are generally consistent across patients with similar conditions, involving minimal customization beyond coil placement and intensity adjustments. MeRT, on the other hand, takes personalization to a more sophisticated level by analyzing individual brain function patterns before designing a unique stimulation program. The treatment is highly customized to address neural activity associated with various mental health conditions.

QEEG Integration

TMS typically does not incorporate qEEG in its standard application, relying instead on anatomical landmarks and predetermined stimulation parameters. MeRT therapy fundamentally depends on qEEG analysis to create a brain “fingerprint” that guides the entire treatment process. It allows practitioners to identify dysfunctional neural networks and target them specifically.

Session Structure

TMS sessions follow a relatively fixed format with predetermined stimulation patterns and specific durations. MeRT procedures involve periodic qEEG recordings to assess current brain activity, followed by customized stimulation that may change from one treatment to the next based on the patient’s neurological response and progress.

Potential Side Effects

Both techniques have mild side effects, such as headaches and scalp discomfort. However, MeRT’s personalized approach may reduce these adverse reactions by avoiding unnecessary stimulation of properly functioning neural networks. One should note that TMS side effects are well-documented through years of clinical use, while MeRT’s unique approach might have a different risk profile in some instances. Nevertheless, both treatments are generally safe and do not entail severe reactions when performed by skilled providers.

Regulatory Approval

TMS has secured FDA approval for multiple conditions, including major depressive disorder, obsessive-compulsive disorder, anxious depression, and smoking cessation. MeRT currently has limited regulatory recognition, with all applications considered off-label use. However, the equipment that is utilized in MeRT is mostly FDA-approved.

Cost

TMS costs $100-$300 per session without insurance. MeRT treatment generally commands premium pricing, ranging from $200 to $500 for one procedure. This difference reflects the additional technology, expertise, and personalization involved in MeRT therapy.

Insurance Coverage

Many insurance plans now reimburse TMS for FDA-approved applications, such as treatment-resistant depression, with established eligibility criteria. On the other hand, coverage for MeRT remains significantly more limited, with many patients paying out-of-pocket due to its classification as an emerging technology.

Which Mental Health Disorders Can Be Treated?

Major Depressive Disorder

TMS has received FDA approval for treating severe major depressive disorder that has not responded to medication, providing hope for patients who have not benefited from traditional therapies. MeRT alleviates symptoms of this disorder by identifying specific neural patterns through qEEG analysis and delivering precise magnetic pulses to restore healthy brain communication pathways.

Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder

dTMS and rTMS protocols stimulate various regions implicated in OCD, providing relief for patients with complex symptoms. Similarly, MeRT treatment focuses on normalizing dysregulated brain areas associated with obsessive thinking and compulsive behaviors, offering a personalized approach that addresses specific neural patterns.

Anxiety

TMS is increasingly used for anxiety disorders, targeting the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex to improve emotional regulation. MeRT can identify and address neural signatures associated with hyperarousal, offering tailored treatment that addresses the unique pattern of brainwave activity underlying each individual’s anxiety symptoms.

Addiction

The FDA has approved a specific TMS protocol using the BrainsWay H4 coil to target the insular cortex and other pathways for reducing substance abuse. MeRT focuses on normalizing neural circuits associated with reward processing and craving, providing a personalized approach to combating addiction.

Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder

TMS treatment for PTSD typically targets the prefrontal cortex to enhance top-down regulation of the amygdala and other limbic structures involved in fear responses. MeRT approaches this problem by identifying the disrupted brainwave patterns associated with hypervigilance and emotional dysregulation, creating individualized protocols that address each patient’s unique needs.

Autism

TMS shows promise for improving specific symptoms of autism spectrum disorder by targeting regions related to social cognition and repetitive behaviors. MeRT treatment for this condition focuses on identifying and normalizing atypical brainwave patterns, supporting communication, emotional regulation, and sensory processing.

Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder

TMS for ADHD typically targets the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex to enhance executive function and attention networks, improving concentration and impulse control. MeRT maps the specific neural patterns in each individual that may underlie hyperactivity and other problems.

Bipolar Disorder

TMS can be utilized during the low phases of bipolar disorder, targeting depression symptoms while carefully monitoring mood stability. MeRT’s personalized approach helps patients with this disorder by addressing the neural patterns associated with depressive states with maximum precision.

Chronic Pain

TMS protocols for chronic pain target the motor cortex and other pain-processing regions, offering a non-medication treatment for conditions like fibromyalgia and neuropathic pain. MeRT also addresses these problems, providing an effective technique for patients seeking alternatives to conventional pain management.

Traumatic Brain Injury

TMS offers promise for alleviating specific TBI symptoms, such as headaches, cognitive deficits, and mood disturbances by targeting affected neural networks. MeRT treatment for this condition begins with detailed brain mapping to identify dysregulation patterns resulting from injury. After this procedure, healthcare providers create individualized protocols to improve mental functioning, sleep quality, and emotional state.

TMS vs MeRT: Summary of Differences

TMS

MeRT

Technology
Used

Uses standard TMS devices that generate magnetic pulses

Incorporates qEEG to customize stimulation based on brain activity

Personalizat
ion

Standardized protocols with minimal customization

Highly personalized based on qEEG mapping

qEEG Integration

Fixed stimulation protocols with specific durations of procedures

Adjusts treatment based on qEEG data

Session Structure

No risk (no fat transfer involved)

High risk (fat embolism can be life-threatening)

Side Effects

Mild side effects (headaches, scalp discomfort)

Similar side effects, but customization may reduce unnecessary stimulation

Regulatory Approval

FDA-approved for MDD, OCD, anxious depression, and smoking cessation

Limited regulatory approval; primarily off-label use

Cost

$100-$300 per session without insurance

$200-$500 per session without insurance

Insurance Coverage

Often covered for FDA-approved conditions

Limited coverage; usually out-of-pocket

TMS

MeRT

Technology Used

Uses standard TMS devices that generate magnetic pulses

Technology Used

Uses standard TMS devices that generate magnetic pulses

Personalization

Standardized protocols with minimal customization

Personalization

Highly personalized based on qEEG mapping

qEEG Integration

Not typically included

qEEG Integration

Essential for guiding treatment

Session Structure

Fixed stimulation protocols with specific durations of procedures

Session Structure

Adjusts treatment based on qEEG data

Side Effects

Mild side effects (headaches, scalp discomfort)

Side Effects

Similar side effects, but customization may reduce unnecessary stimulation

Regulatory Approval

FDA-approved for MDD, OCD, anxious depression, and smoking cessation

Regulatory Approval

Limited regulatory approval; primarily off-label use

Cost

$100-$300 per session without insurance

cost

$200-$500 per session without insurance

Insurance Coverage

Often covered for FDA-approved conditions

Insurance Coverage

Limited coverage; usually out-of-pocket

TMS Therapy Near Me Is a Comprehensive Database of TMS and MeRT Providers in the U.S.

Finding the right provider for advanced neuromodulation treatments like TMS and MeRT can be challenging. Considering this problem, we created an extensive database to help patients seeking these innovative therapies. Our portal connects individuals with qualified brain treatment centers throughout the United States, allowing them to quickly locate specialists in their area who offer either traditional TMS or personalized MeRT protocols. By giving detailed information about provider credentials, available treatment options, and facility specializations, TMS Therapy Near Me empowers patients to make informed decisions about their care. Whether you are seeking treatment for depression, anxiety, PTSD, or other conditions that may benefit from magnetic stimulation, our comprehensive directory streamlines the process of finding appropriate services close to home. Try TMS Therapy Near Me today to start your healing journey with maximum convenience.