TMS vs. Spravato
Medication

Mental health issues have become increasingly prevalent 
in today’s fast-paced world. As a result, new treatments are constantly emerging to meet the growing demand. Two prominent options stand out among the many available alternatives: Spravato and transcranial magnetic stimulation therapy. In this blog post, we will explore these treatments to understand their differences, benefits, and practical considerations.

Spravato: A Breakthrough 
in Medication-Assisted Treatment

Spravato, also known as esketamine, is an FDA-approved medication designed for treatment-resistant depression. It is administered as a nasal spray under the supervision of a healthcare professional. Esketamine is the S-enantiomer of ketamine, meaning that it is a more potent form of the drug that can be provided at lower doses. Unlike traditional ketamine, which is typically given intravenously, esketamine is easier to administer under medical supervision. Spravato targets the brain’s glutamate receptors, which are believed to affect mood regulation. This treatment option is particularly beneficial for individuals who have not responded well to traditional medications. The duration of its effects can vary, but it typically lasts a few days.

Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS): Harnessing Magnetic Fields for Mental Health

TMS therapy is a non-invasive procedure that uses magnetic fields to stimulate nerve cells in specific brain regions. It is primarily used 
to address depression symptoms but can also be effective for other mental health conditions, such as anxiety and obsessive-compulsive disorder. Unlike Spravato, TMS therapy does not involve medication and is considered a safe and well-tolerated treatment option. 
It is administered in an outpatient setting over several sessions, each lasting around 30 minutes.

Differences Between TMS and Spravato

Mechanism of Action

TMS therapy and Spravato medication have different mechanisms 
of action for depression treatment. TMS uses electromagnetic coils placed against the scalp to deliver magnetic pulses to the brain’s prefrontal cortex, which controls mood regulation. This activates underactive neural circuits involved in depression. TMS aims to normalize activity in the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex, which becomes less active.
In contrast, Spravato is an NMDA receptor antagonist. It works 
by blocking the action of the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) glutamate receptor, which controls mood and perceptions of reality. By partially inhibiting it, Spravato can provide rapid relief of symptoms before antidepressants fully take effect. The mechanism focuses 
on the glutamate system instead of directly stimulating mood-related brain regions.

Administration

During a TMS session, a technician positions an electromagnetic coil against the patient’s scalp near the forehead. The coil painlessly delivers repetitive pulses that stimulate nerve cells in the target brain region. Sessions typically last 30-60 minutes and do not require sedation 
or anesthesia. There is also theta burst stimulation (TBS), a type of TMS that takes just 3-7 minutes.
In contrast, Spravato is the brand name for esketamine, a medication derived from ketamine. It is used as a nasal spray that is absorbed through the lining of the nose into the bloodstream. Spravato is self-administered in conjunction with an oral antidepressant under the supervision of a healthcare provider. Before getting the spray, patients are assessed for contraindications and side effects. The treatment 
is provided in a healthcare setting where the patient sits or lies down and remains for at least 2 hours after taking medication for continued monitoring. This allows medical supervision in case of sedation, dissociation, or other adverse reactions.
The main difference in administration is that TMS is an external procedure performed by a technician, while Spravato is a nasal spray taken 
by the patient under medical supervision. TMS does not require sedation or recovery time. Spravato, on the other hand, includes a period 
of monitoring. Both treatments involve in-office sessions, but the administration mode and time commitment differ significantly.

Side Effects

TMS therapy and Spravato tend to have different side effect profiles. TMS therapy is generally well-tolerated with minimal adverse reactions. The most common issues include headaches, lightheadedness, scalp discomfort at the stimulation site, and facial twitching. These side effects are mild and typically go away immediately after treatment.
Spravato, on the other hand, has more significant adverse reactions due to its dissociative properties as a ketamine-based medication. Common side effects include dissociation, distorted perceptions, dizziness, nausea, vertigo, anxiety, lethargy, increased blood pressure, and loss of consciousness. These adverse reactions peak shortly after taking Spravato and are closely monitored by a healthcare provider. Some side effects may linger for hours after treatment.

Due to the more intense psychedelic-like reactions to Spravato, patients require much closer medical supervision and monitoring after taking it. TMS therapy does not alter consciousness or perception, allowing people to return to normal activity immediately.

Some patients may find the side effects of Spravato difficult to tolerate, whereas TMS therapy causes minimal disruption in daily life. Discussing the differences in potential side effects with a doctor can help determine which treatment option is more suitable for your needs and sensitivities.

Duration of Treatment

TMS therapy for depression typically involves 20-30 sessions over 4-6 weeks. After the initial treatment course, maintenance TMS is sometimes recommended – usually one session per month or per week over 6-12 months to sustain the antidepressant effect. In comparison, Spravato usually starts with the induction phase – two sessions per week for 1-4 weeks alongside an oral antidepressant. After this initial step, the frequency is reduced to once weekly for weeks 5-8. Maintenance may continue at a reduced frequency in people who have responded well. In summary, the initial phase for TMS is shorter at 4-6 weeks, whereas Spravato usually takes around two months. Both treatments may involve a maintenance period of monthly or weekly sessions to prevent relapse of depressive symptoms. Depending on the patient’s needs and response, the maintenance phase can last 6-12 months or longer for either TMS or Spravato.

Cost

There are also significant differences in costs associated with each treatment. In the United States, an entire course of TMS therapy typically ranges from $6,000 to $15,000. Many insurance plans now cover TMS, given its FDA clearance for reducing depressive symptoms. Out-of-pocket costs depend on coverage, but copays often vary from 
$0 to $200 per session. Qualification for coverage varies by carrier. In most cases, insurance companies want evidence that the patient has tried and failed 1-4 antidepressant medications, such as selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors.

The cost of Spravato medication varies based on the patient’s condition and needs, 
so it is best to consult a doctor for accurate pricing. Insurance coverage is also possible. After receiving price quotes from their providers and discussing potential reimbursements, patients can calculate the financial differences between TMS 
and Spravato.

Suitability

TMS therapy is typically suitable for patients with major depressive disorder. It is also generally safe for most people, including older adults. The only absolute contraindications are having metallic objects near the head 
or certain neurological conditions, such as seizures. TMS does not interact 
with medications.

Spravato, on the other hand, has stricter criteria. It is only FDA-approved for treatment-resistant depression in conjunction with an oral antidepressant. Due to the risk of sedation and dissociation from the ketamine, patients must be monitored in a certified healthcare setting for at least 2 hours after receiving their medication. It is not suitable for people with certain cardiovascular risks. Caution must also be taken when combining Spravato with certain other medications due to the risk of interactions.

TMS therapy is suitable for a broader population of patients with depression, whereas Spravato has stricter inclusion criteria, monitoring requirements, and risk factors that would exclude certain people. Healthcare providers conduct suitability assessments to determine which treatment option 
is better for each individual’s needs and medical history.

Accessibility

TMS therapy is available at specialized clinics and medical centers. It is becoming more widely available due to its remarkable benefits and growing demand. While there may be geographical challenges for some people, there are many areas in which TMS centers are just a few short miles away. TMS requires 30-60-minute daily sessions over 4-6 weeks, which is a significant commitment, but it can be done on 1-hour breaks from work. In contrast, Spravato is administered twice weekly at a clinic or medical office, requiring less frequent visits. However, sessions are longer because they include a 2-hour monitoring period. Therefore, it might be harder to receive this treatment during breaks from work.

Conclusion

When considering the right treatment option for your mental health needs, it is crucial to consult with a healthcare professional who can assess your situation. Factors like the severity of the condition, previous history, and potential side effects must be considered. Each treatment option discussed in this blog post has unique benefits and limitations. However, both Spravato and TMS offer hope for those who have not responded well to traditional medications. TMS therapy is an effective drug-free treatment, while Spravto is a medication that acts differently than standard antidepressants. Everyone’s journey towards mental well-being is different, and what works for one person may not be suitable for another. By understanding the distinctions between Spravato and TMS therapy, you can make an informed decision that satisfies your specific needs. Always consult with a healthcare professional to determine the best course of action for mental health treatment. We offer an extensive database to help you find the best TMS providers and start therapy today!